These cut-out sugar cookies are a Halloween tradition for a reason, and they happen to be a great project to hand off to little helpers. The dough holds its shape crisply so your bats stay batty and your pumpkins stay plump, and a two-color icing keeps the decorating quick and satisfyingly spooky.
Cookies that hold their shape
Chill the dough both before and after cutting so the shapes stay sharp in the oven. Roll to an even quarter-inch and they will bake up uniform, with those clean, crisp edges you want for outlining.
Two colors, endless fun
All you really need is black and orange. Outline each shape with a slightly thicker icing, then flood the middle with a thinner one, nudging it into the corners with a toothpick. That is all it takes for tidy bat wings and pumpkin ridges.
Prep ahead
The dough freezes for up to three months, and decorated cookies keep in a tin for a week — perfect for getting ahead before the party.